Archiv für die Kategorie ‘1’

h1

Learning at Stations: Gandhi II

Juli 1, 2008

Watch the clip (Gandhi II) and briefly say what is parodied here.

- Gandhi’s non-violent resistance; here he’s shown as a criminal

- lives a luxury life (materialism); eats a steak(‘the holy cow’ -> normally he’s a vegetarian and lives an ascetic life)

In the documentary “In Search of Gandhi” one of the interviewed states that today Gandhi would grab a gun. Explain why he thinks so and comment on whether you think he is right.

The interviewed says that today Gandhi would grab a gun. So I guess he means that nowadays everybody would use weapons to win a fight or war. Nobody would even try to practice non-violent resistance because it seems nearly impossible to win without violence.
However, I don’t think that today Gandhi would grab a gun, because he was committed to his ideas of passive resistance and always tried to dispose them to revise their opinion about violence. Therefore today he would support his philosophy as well.

h1

Gandhi – The Movie: Questions

Juni 25, 2008

5. Gandhi meets Charlie Andrews, the English clergyman, and they walk downtown together. What book does Gandhi quote from when they are about to met up with some aggressive white South Africans? Do you think that is unusual for a Hindu?

When they walk downtown together, Gandhi quotes from the New Testament. He says something like „Love your neighbour as yourself; Jews, Sikhs, Hindus..“ This shows that Gandhi was very open-minded to other religions, e.g. the Christendom. He also knows a lot about other religions and the belief of the people; so he’s able to assess the Christians. I don’t think that it’s usual for a Hindu to quote from the Bible, because not everybody accepts all religions like Gandhi did.

10. Charlie Andrews, the English clergyman, gives a Sunday sermon which supports Gandhi. What happens? Do you see any irony in this?

When Charlie Andrews talks about Gandhi and his philosophy, many people leave the ceremony, because they don’t agree with Andrews. However, there are also believers who understand Gandhi like the clergyman does. They stay in the church and agree with Andrews by nodding.

15. After Gandhi is paid a visit by a poor and starving farmer, he goes to that area of India and learns about the farming system that the British impose on the Indian farmers. Give a detailed account of what the system is and relate it to the British philosophy towards India.

- the Indian farmers are very poor, because their landlords take everything from them. 
- have no money and can’t pay anything.
- even don’t have food by reason that the landlords have taken the rest.

20. The end of Part One focuses on one of Gandhi’s fasts. What is the purpose of the fast? What components of spirituality are incorporated into fasting?

With his fasts Gandhi wants to show the British their failures and also wants to stop the disturbances. Maybe he also wants the positive effect of the fast (come to your senses) to devolve to the British.

h1

Gandhi-The Movie: Key scenes

Juni 19, 2008

1) Gandhi’s speech

In this scene Gandhi talks about his philosophy of passive resistance: Later the audience stands and claps, which shows that they’re willing to follow him.

2) Gandhi’s fasts

With his fasts Gandhi has a strong influence on other people: He manages to change the Indians’ minds so that they stop their fightings. This scene is also very important, because Gandhi shows that he would be willing to die for his belief.

3) salt march

In my opinion the salt march is one of the most important key scenes. Gandhi’s march has the strongest influence on the people, Indians and British. The British feel the dimensions of Gandhi’s power.

4) quotation: ‘ I’m Muslim, Hindu, Christian, Jew…“

This quotation shows that Gandhi was keen to create a community of all religions. He described himself as a Muslim, Hindu, Jew… to reveal that all peole are the same and there are no better people.

5) Gandhi’s funeral

The funeral scene shows the popularity of Gandhi. The masses of people who follow his coffin seem to be his devotees who followed his ideas even after Gandhi’s death.

6) assassination scene

The assassination scene which is already shown at the beginning of the movie, changes its effect on the viewer: in the end you feel with Gandhi, because you got to know him better during the movie. You know a lot about his great ideas and philosophy, but in a way, you can also comprehend the fanatic Hindu who kills him: Gandhi’s ideas have splitted the people which was possibly the trigger for the assassination.